The short answer
Run a garden hose into the gutter's high end for a few minutes and watch the underside from the ground. Water dripping at a joint, rather than flowing into the downpipe, shows where the seal has failed and where a repair is needed.
Only if you can do it safely from the ground
For a single-storey or low gutter you can reach from the ground, the test is simple. If you cannot reach, skip it and send photos on WhatsApp instead.
The hose test
- Clear the gutter first, or the test will tell you nothing.
- With a helper watching from the ground, run the hose at the high end of the run.
- Let it run for a few minutes at a moderate flow.
- Watch for drips along the underside, especially at joints, stop ends and where the gutter meets the downpipe.
What the drip pattern tells you
- A drip at a joint means the seal or gasket has failed.
- A drip at the end cap means the stop end has come loose or lost its sealant.
- Water running down the wall beside the downpipe at the top suggests a poorly seated outlet.
- No drip but water spilling over the front means a blockage or low spot, not a leak.
The usual fix
Plastic gutters use a rubber seal in a clip joint; the seal can perish and be replaced. Cast-iron joints are bolted and sealed with putty or mastic; the old sealant is removed and replaced. Both are small jobs when caught early.
Stop and call a professional if: reaching the gutter would need a ladder, or you would have to lean over a conservatory, porch or first-floor roof to run the hose.